Navigating the Offer stage: Practical Insights for Tax

In this episode of Ambition Talks: Tax Careers, tax recruitment specialists Claire Cheung and Chris Cheng discuss the intricacies of navigating the offer stage for Tax Director roles in Public Practice.

They cover the key considerations candidates should keep in mind when reviewing and negotiating offers, including the importance of being upfront about current salary and bonus structures, understanding salary bands, and evaluating total compensation beyond base pay. The conversation highlights practical tips for negotiating benefits such as pension contributions and private healthcare, as well as the importance of managing timing and communication when responding to offers.

Claire and Chris also explore how to handle multiple offers and counteroffers, providing guidance to help tax professionals make informed decisions and negotiate effectively in a competitive market. They emphasise the value of transparency, professionalism, and strategic communication throughout the offer process to ensure a successful transition.

Navigating the Offer: Practical Insights for Tax Directors

Transcript

Claire:

Welcome to Episode Four of Ambition Talks: Tax Careers – Navigating the Offer. Thank you for joining us today. In this episode, we’re diving into practical insights for tax directors navigating the offer negotiation stage of your job search. We’ll share tips, best practices, and real experiences to help you through this critical stage.

Please note, while we’ll discuss recommended strategies, they may not apply universally and will depend on your personal circumstances. We always tailor our guidance accordingly.

Let me quickly introduce the team: I’m Claire Cheung, here with Christian, and Tasnima supports VAT, direct tax, and private client tax roles— unfortunately, she couldn’t join us live today.
Here’s what we’ll cover:

Getting offer-ready: what info to share with your recruiter (and why)
Salary reviews, bandings, market influence, and how to shape your offer
Additional package elements—beyond basic salary—and the impact of timing
Real-world scenarios and case studies
Your questions answered

Let’s dive into getting offer-ready and the importance of your early conversations with your recruiter.

Claire:

Hi everyone. In this session, we’ll share practical tips and strategies to help you successfully navigate the offer process — from understanding your total compensation to negotiating benefits and managing multiple offers.

1. The Offer Stage: What to Expect

Claire:
Once you reach the offer stage, it’s crucial to be upfront about your current salary and bonus. Transparency here builds trust and helps set realistic expectations.

Chris:
Exactly. Beyond base salary, candidates should focus on the total package, including pension contributions, private healthcare, bonuses, and other benefits.

Claire:
Being honest with your recruiter is crucial in order to get you the best offer possible on the table.

It’s essential to share your current compensation and expectations early with your recruiter. We revisit this conversation throughout the process to align on evolving expectations and budget limitations.

Chris:
If your situation changes, let us know. Surprises at the end of the process are rarely helpful. Also, detail your full compensation: pension, insurance, bonus components, and especially bonus payout timings—this can affect your resignation timing.

Claire:
We’ve seen delays of months due to unanticipated bonus payments. In such cases, we can sometimes negotiate sign-on bonuses to bridge the gap. But don’t leave it too late.

Chris:
If you have upcoming salary reviews, inform us early. It helps us prepare a stronger negotiation case and manage timelines.

2. Understanding Salary Bands and Total Compensation

Claire:
Many candidates fixate on base salary, but it’s important to look at the full compensation picture. Ask about salary bands and where you might fit based on your experience and skills.

Chris:
Also, clarify how bonuses are structured—are they guaranteed or discretionary? What’s the typical range? This knowledge helps you negotiate confidently.

3. Negotiating Benefits

Claire:
Benefits like pension schemes and private healthcare can significantly impact your overall reward. Don’t hesitate to discuss these during negotiations—they’re often negotiable.

Chris:
Right. Other perks might include flexible working arrangements, car allowances, or professional development budgets. Understand what matters most to you and bring it up early.

Claire:

Don’t focus solely on base salary. Director-level packages include:

Car/cash allowance
Firm-wide/discretionary bonus
Pension contributions
Private medical insurance, life cover, income protection
Annual leave and leave buy-back options

Chris:
Ask about bonus metrics early, ideally during business plan discussions. Also, understand pension structures—salary sacrifice and matching schemes can significantly impact your take-home.

Claire:
Medical coverage varies. Know what’s covered—self, spouse, family? Understand the cost of replacing lost coverage.

Annual leave is frequently overlooked. Does your current employer provide extra leave? Christmas shutdowns, birthdays, volunteering days? These differences can add up significantly.

4. Managing Timing When Responding to Offers

Claire:
When you receive an offer, take time to review it carefully, but don’t delay too long in responding. Keep communication open and honest about your decision timeline.

Chris:
If you need extra time to consider or negotiate, ask. Recruiters can often help facilitate this to avoid losing the opportunity.

Once you receive an offer, take time to consider it, but don’t delay too long. Sitting too long on an offer may give the impression you’re not committed.

Claire:

"Time kills deals" is a common saying. When managing multiple offers, ideally, you want them all on the table at the same time—but that's rarely the case. If needed, we will manage expectations with other firms.

Be transparent about other offers—even if we didn’t represent you in them. It helps us advocate on your behalf.

5. Handling Multiple Offers and Counteroffers

Claire:
If you’re fortunate to have multiple offers, evaluate each against your career goals, culture fit, and long-term prospects—not just salary.

Chris:
Be cautious with counteroffers. While tempting, they can complicate relationships and your professional reputation if not handled carefully. If you're unsure about how to deal with counter offers then feel free to speak to your recruiter for guidance.

Many of our candidates are unsure about how to resign and this can seem quite tricky but the best approach is to speak to your manager and thank them for their support and then usually email your manager your formal resignation so HR can register your resignation. Each firm is different, but this is the standard process. One of my candidates received a counteroffer after resigning. Multiple partners contacted them trying to convince them to stay. They offered money and incentives, but the candidate stayed focused on their long-term goals and formally resigned. Once that happened, the pressure stopped.

Claire:
Hybrid working is another vital factor. Many directors are expected to be in-office more frequently. Be upfront about your needs—whether that's due to childcare, relocation, or commute costs.

Chris:
Firms are changing hybrid policies rapidly. Don’t base your decision on current arrangements alone. Ask about flexibility and long-term expectations.

6. Final Tips

Claire:
Maintain professionalism throughout. Even if negotiations get tough, staying respectful and transparent ensures you leave a positive impression.

Chris:
And remember, your recruiter is your advocate—use their expertise to navigate tricky conversations and understand market standards.

Claire:
Thanks for joining us in Episode 4 of Ambition Talks: Tax Careers. We hope these insights help you confidently handle your next Tax Director offer.

Chris:
If you have questions or want personalised advice, feel free to reach out. We’re here to support your career every step of the way.

Claire:

Join us for the next episode, where we'll discuss how to succeed in your first 90 days as a Tax Director!

About the speaker

Claire Cheung is an experienced Tax recruiter at Ambition, working closely with Big 4, Top 10, Top 100 and boutique practices. Claire specialises in placing Director and Partner level candidates across all taxes, and US Tax and Global Mobility candidates at all levels .

Contact the team